Hood Underground
heart and soul of our Fort Hood community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Hood Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com

Any one watching TYRA?

who's talking here?

2010 2
GreatNinjaYuffie 1
KellyP 2
I ♥ NY 2
*Jamie* 3
someonesangel 1
Mamma Tia 2
granny 2
~*Tamara*~ 3
AlterEgo 2
the1 1
Tango wifey 2
MorganK 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

2010 --- 16 years ago -

They are talking about spanking... Do you spank your child or do you try alternate ideas? 

*Jamie* --- 16 years ago -

Both 

GreatNinjaYuffie --- 16 years ago -

I don't spank. Hubby makes them do Army stuff which they said they would rather get spanked lol. 

2010 --- 16 years ago -

I don't spank. Hubby makes them do Army stuff which they said they would rather get spanked lol. lmao!!! 

someonesangel --- 16 years ago -

in sweden it's illegal to spank your child. my child is too young, but i don't know if I could do it.. lol. 

KellyP --- 16 years ago -

I've spanked but it never did any good but make the child upset with me for being "mean". When my kids were really little I would "thick" them and that got the point across without being "mean". Now...no matter what I do they don't seem to care. I am a yeller, it seems the only way the ever hear me :) 

granny --- 16 years ago -

Taking things away or time out never worked with either of my girls. I spanked mine (didn't have to often) I got the mean look that they hate to see (unless its directed at someone else and not them)and they would straighten up, but now that they are grown and really mess up I just have to speak really quite and they know that I have been pushed way to far. When they really have to stop and listen and they kinda get the point. But I am a yeller to so they are used to it. 

the1 --- 16 years ago -

I do it all cuz my kids get immune to it all after awhile so i hav to switch it up. my dad didnt spank us he would make us kneel and we would end up fallin asleep there if we were inside cuz he would fall asleep. but he would do that to if we were outside on rocks and that would so hurt. my mom yelled and my aunt and grandma used the switch when they could get me lol. but with my kids i spank, i dont use my hands i normally use a belt, and they lay on bed and i explain if they move its gonna hurt more cuz i want to hit there bottom not there legs or back cuz that would so hurt so much more. and then at times i make em kneel then its just go to ur room and i hav already taken all there things out there room literally so they nothing to do but homework. and my kids r still bad so i do reward em when they do good that i even cry cuz am so happy. probly more than ne one wants to read cuz i tend to ramble sorry hope it makes sense 

Tango wifey --- 16 years ago -

i used to spank but he is almost 15 now so we take away the internet or Xbox. 

MorganK --- 16 years ago -

Depends on what they did. Mostly we do time out or take things away, but the thing that gets them doing the right thing is just a threaten of a spanking. 

~*Tamara*~ --- 16 years ago -

I will probably spank if it's needed. I do pop my daughters hands when she is getting into things or touching things she is not suppose to. Usually yelling in a harsh tone gets her attention better and sometimes works better also if I scare her in the process. 

Mamma Tia --- 16 years ago -

I will most likely spank when needed. I feel that within reason there is no problem with it. Of course Emma is only 5 months now and I don't spank her now lol that'd be crazy. But I will not allow her to "gum" on my hand or arm or anything and pulling hair is a no no. She gets a firm "no" and her mouth or hand gets moved away. If she is pulling my hair I will say "No" firmly and very very gently tap her hand with one finger until she lets go. I know its all innocent now but for me it's all about consistency. 

I ♥ NY --- 16 years ago -

We just discussed this topic in my Crisis Intervention class... majority of my class was for spanking as long as it was ocassional, and appropriate. I myself am for it... BUT, I do believe that your child has to learn to respect you, and not through fear. Fear is not respect. I barely have had to spank my daughter, time outs and punishments usually do the trick, and she dare never talk over me. I also make sure whether its a reprimand, spanking, or punishment, I make sure SHE can explain to me what she did wrong, and why she got in trouble. So I know she understood. Thats important to me cuz I never want her to think shes getting in trouble for no reason, or the wrong reasons. 

Tango wifey --- 16 years ago -

I agree with that Tia i have never let my son play hit or wrestle with me i just don't go there. 

AlterEgo --- 16 years ago -

Spanking is a form of child abuse. Anybody who grew up being spanked knows how traumatic spanking is. It is always easier to spank than take time to teach your child why he/she shouldn't do certain things. It is all about PREVENTION. You can't punish your kid after the fact if he/she did not know he/she wasn't supposed to do that. You guys are very young, but it is still wrong for you to use physical or mental punishment. Your child should not be afraid of you, because he/she will grow up having some sort of mental problem otherwise, there's no other way around it. Low self esteem, aggression, depression, tolerance towards physical abuse just to name a few. You wouldn't want your husband to slap you around when you're being unreasonable, would you? Then why do you do this to your kids? Please do not spank, use time out, talk, tell them you are upset and angry with them, but please do not lay hands on your kids(or call them names)guys. You chose to have them, it is your selfish decision, they did not chose to be born, so your world is supposed to revolve around them. I ♥ NY I do not who teaches your class, but any adequate child psychologist will tell you that spanking is not ok. 

MorganK --- 16 years ago -

 

~*Tamara*~ --- 16 years ago -

Spanking is a form of child abuse. Anybody who grew up being spanked knows how traumatic spanking is. I'm sorry but I find this funny. Everyone but 1 in my family has been spanked at one point or another in our life growing up.My youngest cousin was "spoiled" and guess where his sorry ass is for another 23 years. Prison ! The rest of us all have our lives together. Most of us are married and have kids. Not saying we are "perfect" but we damn sure are not traumatized. 

*Jamie* --- 16 years ago -

I grew up being spanked and I am not in the least bit traumatized. I learned that if I did not want a spanking then I need to behave. Easy as that. My kids are not afraid of me and they do not get spanked for not knowing any better. You might want to take a look at the law on spanking because it is indeed not child abuse. If you are consistent and use spanking as a last resort for specific behaviors then you should not have to spank very often. 

AlterEgo --- 16 years ago -

~*Tamara*~ *Jamie* You guys can say you are not traumatized all you want but unless you let me talk to you with a therapist present, I don't know whether or not you are telling the truth, no offense. Remember that "King of the Hill" episode, when Bill says :" I've been spanked as a child and I turned out ok.......Master..." :) On a serious note though, I've met pathological liars that would spank their kids and tell me that they were spanked and turned out ok, obviously it wasn't the case. They have learned to lie to avoid getting in trouble at a very young age and now they are suffering the consequences (not mentioning the suffering their husbands and kids go through). Do you think they admit to having psychological problems? Anything you say or do to a kid will affect your child in a future. And I mean every single thing you do or say. You might not believe me, but that's why there are books on parenting and child psychology out there. If you learn to drive a car, you should learn how to raise a child, it does not come naturally and you should never copy your parents' parenting style. Anyways, you can be in favor or against spanking, but you should know its a form of a child abuse( you might think it' not, but it is). You are teaching your kids to use violence to solve problems, you are teaching them to lie, so they don't get spanked, you are making them think that violence is ok and whoever is stronger is alays right. If mommy breaks something or accidentally falls over when she tries to do something stupid(mommies do that too) does she gets slapped by daddy? Why not? Why do you think you do not deserve a physical punishment when you do something you are not supposed to? Why do you think your child does? Because you are in power and child can't fight back? Or is it because you can do no wrong? Do not get mad at me, but try to analyze what I have told you. If you want what's best for your children you will find other ways to get through to them. Kids can be overwhelming but you need to keep your cool, because as I said before, you chose to have them. 

*Jamie* --- 16 years ago -

So now I'm a liar. LOL Like I said before my kids have never been spanked for an accident. You are not in my home and do not see how I deal with my children so I will wave my little white flag because nothing is going to change your mind. My children are healthy and happy no matter what any stranger who doesn't know us says. 

I ♥ NY --- 16 years ago -

Alterego I've have many hours of child psychology courses under my belt, as well as violent relationships, and childhood trauma. As well as being a Trained/Certified Mandated Reporter by CPS... Occasional, rational, and not forceful spanking is not child abuse. Not even in a legal aspect. I ♥ NY I do not who teaches your class, but any adequate child psychologist will tell you that spanking is not ok. Curious, since you want to question my college professor’s credibility, what are your credentials exactly? Are you a licensed "adequate" child psychologist? 

Mamma Tia --- 16 years ago -

I agree with I ♥ NY. I too have a degree in psychology and every professor, I have had would back me up in saying that within reason spanking is not child abuse. We are not saying we take a paddle and forcefully hit a bare bottom till bruised. Spanking and beating are two seperate things. I was spanked as a child and I can tell you without doubt that it has not traumatized me. Looking back, I deserved it, I did things I knew I shouldn't and I knew that a spanking was the consequence. I was never suprised when I was spanked because I knew that was the consequence. I take offense to being told that I am in some way screwed up because I was disciplined as a child. Also, no one will tell me that I abuse my child, especially someone who has no idea what goes on in my household, what other methods of discipline I use, and how I handle situations. and I ask the same question what are your credentials exactly? Are you a licensed "adequate" child psychologist?  

granny --- 16 years ago -

You wouldn't want your husband to slap you around when you're being unreasonable, would you? Then why do you do this to your kids? Noone said sh!t about slapping our children around. And domestic violence is a whole other subject that has nothing to do with disiplining a child. Spanking is a form of child abuse. Anybody who grew up being spanked knows how traumatic spanking is. I find this funny as hell. Let me guess, you would have all of todays children running around wild and having not to answer for all of the ill deeds that they have done. And anyone that was "spanked" will not be tramataized by this. That is an excuse that people need to look into their own anger. You are teaching your kids to use violence to solve problems, You should really do more homework on this, I have the most mild mannered child alive, and will not result to violence because why, she's not a violent person despite being spanked. Oh and by the way, anyone can write a book and if they think they can make a buck or two someone will publish it. Parenting books are everywhere and whats right for one person isn't right for the next. 

~*Tamara*~ --- 16 years ago -

LOL I think someone should of beat some sense into you ... :) 

KellyP --- 16 years ago -

Anyways, you can be in favor or against spanking, but you should know its a form of a child abuse( you might think it' not, but it is). You are teaching your kids to use violence to solve problems, If history means anything...back in the day when 90% of us were popped, smacked, belted, etc there were no school shootings and major forms of public violence as there is now that 90% of parents are shamed, scared, threatened with CPS, etc out of physical forms of punishment on a child. Oh wait, that's because of tv and video games...nevermind! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Hood Underground