Hood Underground
heart and soul of our Fort Hood community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Hood Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com

POLL: Bday parties..... is it rude to not bring a present or is it ok?

who's talking here?

Ashley =] 1
Michell 3
KellyP 1
Another1 1
Redneck Martha Stewart 1
Vagirl™ 1
Luke's Mommy 1
εiз R.B.M.P. 1
*Jamie* 1
Megz 1
Jillian 1
Chunky Butt Funky 1
whisper 2
~*Tamara*~ 1
{Morgan} 1
mustangs 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

POLL: Bday parties..... is it rude to not bring a present or is it ok?

Ok we had my daughters bday party tonight, we invited twenty kids out of that twenty only 5 showed up. And not one of them brought her a present or a card. I think that is pathetic, I was raised up that if you were invited to a bday party you take a gift or a card. Am I wrong?

Wrong not to bring a gift? Vote
 
 76.9% (20)
Ok to not bring a gift? Vote
 
 23.1% (6)
Michell --- 17 years ago -

Ok we had my daughters bday party tonight, we invited twenty kids out of that twenty only 5 showed up. And not one of them brought her a present or a card. I think that is pathetic, I was raised up that if you were invited to a bday party you take a gift or a card. Am I wrong? 

Luke's Mommy --- 17 years ago -

I don't think it's necessary to bring a gift, but, I guess it's all about the motive of your party. Not trying to be rude, but, this is just how I see it. My son turned 1 this month, and we specifically said that unless you're family or a very close friend, you really shouldn't bring a present. A) Because our kid has everything under the sun and doesn't need more and B) because we didn't want people to be discouraged from coming because they felt like they needed to spent money on a gift. Plus, some people were my husband's co-workers or bosses, and I just felt weird expecting presents from them. We asked them to bring a side dish instead. Anyway, the short of that is that we throw birthday parties because we just genuinely want to share the day and celebration with our family and friends. Presents are nice, but definitely not needed. If I was just a casual friend of somebody, I wouldn't feel obligated to bring a present. But yeah... at LEAST a card would be nice. That's kinda crazy. Some people just don't think of that though! 

εiз R.B.M.P. --- 17 years ago -

my kids parties are this weekend and we really don't care if anyone brings a gift or not. idk my kids have literally everything lol, so it won't bother me. but if they don't bring a gift i think it would be nice and common courtesy to at least bring a card. 

Vagirl™ --- 17 years ago -

I was raised "if they can bring a gift,then fine,if they cant thats fine too" 

Jillian --- 17 years ago -

if your not family or close friends i would say its ok not to bring a gift, they could at least have brought a card though. 

Chunky Butt Funky --- 17 years ago -

i was always brought up to bring presents. i can see not bringing them for ages 1-3 if the parents say, "hey, don't worry about a gift..." but i guess perhaps a lot of those ppl you invited couldn't get a gift? and a lot of ppl feel ashamed about it and would rather the child not go if they can't bring a gift... idk. it's a new day in age for kid's parties i guess... 

KellyP --- 17 years ago -

I will always bring one unless it's stated that they are optional or to NOT bring one. But, I don't get upset if someone shows to one we have and doesn't bring a gift. There's been so many times we just don't have the money so I either don't let the kids go or we get creative...I wouldn't expect others to give up something they don't have or can't afford for my children's gain...that's MY job! lol 

{Morgan} --- 17 years ago -

I think at least a card is appropriate...if you cannot afford a present. 

Michell --- 17 years ago -

Morgan thats my thoughts exactly....... 

whisper --- 17 years ago -

that and I'm sure you felt bad for your daughter. here you send her to parties with gifts (and no, it isn't about the gift.. it's the thought behind it) and then she has her party. awful. Well, if for nothing else, it's a good lesson for her in being gracious. And someone else mentioned the cost and ability of a family to get a gift. I would rather have the kids there (which I'm sure you feel the same) but I know how you must feel too. ah well. 

mustangs --- 17 years ago -

Those parents would feel bad if it was the other way around! My daughter had her birthday yesterday but we don't know anyone here but she brought cupcakes to school for her class. It looks like you could afford something. 

whisper --- 17 years ago -

My son's school doesn't allow them to bring ANYTHING in for birthdays. I was stunned. 

~*Tamara*~ --- 17 years ago -

I was brought up to bring a gift if you are invited to any type of party weither they say to or not. 

Ashley =] --- 17 years ago -

I was brought up to bring a gift if you are invited to any type of party weither they say to or not. Ditto to that 

Another1 --- 17 years ago -

While I'd love to be PC about it, the truth (for me that is) is while I don't care if I get gifts for my birthday, I know my kids would be hurt if they didn't. So to me, when it's a child's birthday, and they're of the school age, a gift is appropriate. They're too young to fully comprehend the "it's the thought that counts" sentiment and while it may be a way to "teach them" they'll still be upset that no one got them anything. And, I can tell you from first hand experience with my daughter, it does hurt them. 

Redneck Martha Stewart --- 17 years ago -

If I cant bring a gift, then I at least get a really cool card. Im known for the awesome cards! 

Megz (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

im the same as a few of you I was brought up to bring at least a card and a small gift even if its a dollar tree gift. however if people cant afford it (like many cant especially with the economy the way it is) i dont think its rude to not bring one. but at the very least they could have had the kids make a card from construction or computer paper. 

*Jamie* --- 17 years ago -

I agree with Another1. 

Michell --- 17 years ago -

Yes Amanda it does hurt the kids.... I just think its kinda rude I mean they could have at least brought a card... You can get one from WalMart for 44 cents.... 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Hood Underground